The Marshal Menu
18 items in 5 sections · $4.50 – $16.00 · American Restaurant in New York, NY
The Marshal’s menu lists 18 dishes and drinks, grouped into Cocktails, Virgin Cocktails, Beer & Cider, Local Sodas, and Coffee & Tea. Prices range from $4.50 to $16.00, and a typical item costs about $12.00. Popular choices include Manhattan, Virgin Negroni, Pale Ale, Coffee, and Boylan Brooklyn Sodas.
Cocktails 6
- Manhattan$16.00
Local five & 20 bourbon, sweet vermouth, bitters, preserved cherry
- Negroni$16.00
Local gin, 6pm liqueur, sweet Vermouth
- Pumpkin Spice-cicle$15.00
local vodka & cream, pumpkin syrup, spices, coffee liqueur
- White Mule$15.00
Local vodka, ginger beer, candied ginger
- Elderflower Blossom$15.00
Local elderflower liqueur, Q grapefruit soda, Meyer farm vodka, fresh mint
- Perfect Pear$15.00
Pear puree, local vodka, handcrafted pear liqueur, served up, preserved mandarin
Virgin Cocktails 2
- Virgin Negroni$12.00
Pomegranate, green mandarin, and cardamom
- Virgin Lemongrass Spritz$12.00
Lemon, lemongrass syrup, sparkling water, preserved lemon
Beer & Cider 7
- Pale Ale$8.00
Bronx brewery, 12 oz
- Pilsner$8.00
Montauk brewing co, 12 oz
- City Light Lager$8.00
5 boroughs brewing co, 12 oz
- Kill Van Kolsch$8.00
Flagship brewing CO
- IPA$8.00
Montauk brewing co, 12oz
- Black Duck Porter$12.00
Greenport Harbor, 16oz
- Dry Rose Cider$12.00
Wolffer, 375ml
Local Sodas 1
- Boylan Brooklyn Sodas
Coffee & Tea 2
- Coffee$4.50
Brazilian dark roast
- Pot of Tea$6.50
Blended by Porto Rico coffee & tea- earl grey | English breakfast | sencha green | herbal peppermint spice | chamomile
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.